Though Ohio is in the midrange of U.S. states in terms of crime rates, with the 25th lowest property crime rate and 18th lowest violent crime rate, a considerable number of its cities earned very high scores on our Safety Index, which factors in FBI crime stats and law enforcement employment numbers to judge the safety of a community.
In all, 50 Ohio cities earned a Safety Index score of 0.3 or above, meaning they are very safe communities to live in, while 13 recorded a 0.6 or above, placing them in the upper echelon of U.S. cities in terms of safety. Let’s look at Ohio’s five safest cities to see the best the Buckeye State has to offer.
Maumee is Ohio’s safest city, earning a remarkably high 0.98 Safety Index score. The cozy community of around 14K logged a violent crime rate of 0.36 per 1,000, which is less than a tenth of the national average.
Similarly sized Brecksville recorded even more impressive crime rates, including a 0.15 per 1,000 rate of violent crime and 3.87 per 1,000 rate of property crime. Brecksville is in the #2 position because its ratio of law enforcement officers to residents is lower than #1 Maumee’s.
Ranking third, Cleveland suburb Solon continues Ohio’s streak of low-crime communities, managing a very low 0.56 violent crimes per 1,000 residents. At number four, Wickliffe is not far behind: the city of 12.6K recorded just 9 violent crimes in 2017 for a 0.77 Safety Index score.
New Albany rounds out Ohio’s top five safest communities. The Columbus area suburb recorded less than fifteen violent and property crimes combined in 2017.
Safest Cities in Ohio, 2019
Rank | City | Safety Index |
---|---|---|
1 | Maumee | 0.98 |
2 | Brecksville | 0.97 |
3 | Solon | 0.83 |
4 | Wickliffe | 0.82 |
5 | New Albany | 0.79 |
6 | Sylvania | 0.76 |
7 | Worthington | 0.68 |
8 | Macedonia | 0.67 |
9 | Aurora | 0.66 |
10 | Bedford Heights | 0.65 |
11 | Blue Ash | 0.61 |
12 | Lyndhurst | 0.6 |
13 | Perrysburg Township | 0.6 |
14 | Amherst | 0.59 |
15 | Centerville | 0.55 |
16 | Tiffin | 0.54 |
17 | Seven Hills | 0.53 |
18 | Avon Lake | 0.51 |
19 | Springboro | 0.51 |
20 | Powell | 0.5 |
21 | North Ridgeville | 0.5 |
22 | Clayton | 0.5 |
23 | Hilliard | 0.49 |
24 | Miamisburg | 0.49 |
25 | Harrison | 0.49 |
26 | Brunswick | 0.49 |
27 | Berea | 0.48 |
28 | Bedford | 0.44 |
29 | Streetsboro | 0.43 |
30 | Strongsville | 0.42 |
31 | Poland Township | 0.42 |
32 | Mason | 0.42 |
33 | North Olmsted | 0.41 |
34 | Upper Arlington | 0.39 |
35 | Pierce Township | 0.38 |
36 | Richmond Heights | 0.38 |
37 | Tallmadge | 0.38 |
38 | Mentor | 0.36 |
39 | Kettering | 0.36 |
40 | Monroe | 0.35 |
41 | Gahanna | 0.35 |
42 | Clearcreek Township | 0.35 |
43 | Vandalia | 0.35 |
44 | Cambridge | 0.34 |
45 | Eastlake | 0.33 |
46 | Copley Township | 0.33 |
47 | Wadsworth | 0.33 |
48 | Toledo | 0.31 |
49 | Shawnee Township | 0.31 |
50 | Kent | 0.3 |
51 | Norton | 0.28 |
52 | Delhi Township | 0.27 |
53 | Lakewood | 0.26 |
54 | Ashland | 0.26 |
55 | Bowling Green | 0.24 |
56 | Bexley | 0.23 |
57 | Parma | 0.23 |
58 | Van Wert | 0.2 |
59 | Troy | 0.2 |
60 | Cuyahoga Falls | 0.19 |
61 | Union Township, Clermont County | 0.19 |
62 | Stow | 0.18 |
63 | Cleveland Heights | 0.18 |
64 | Xenia | 0.17 |
65 | Miami Township, Clermont County | 0.17 |
66 | West Carrollton | 0.14 |
67 | Delaware | 0.14 |
68 | Beavercreek | 0.12 |
69 | Defiance | 0.12 |
70 | Forest Park | 0.09 |
71 | Fairfield | 0.08 |
72 | Greenville | 0.08 |
73 | Fairborn | 0.07 |
74 | Springfield Township, Hamilton County | 0.05 |
75 | Englewood | 0.05 |
76 | Austintown | 0.04 |
77 | Huber Heights | 0.04 |
78 | Reading | 0.03 |
79 | Salem | 0.02 |
80 | Mount Vernon | -0.02 |
81 | American Township | -0.03 |
82 | Zanesville | -0.07 |
83 | Reynoldsburg | -0.09 |
84 | Sidney | -0.1 |
85 | Elyria | -0.16 |
86 | Findlay | -0.18 |
87 | Wilmington | -0.19 |
88 | Colerain Township | -0.22 |
89 | Urbana | -0.22 |
90 | Fairfield Township | -0.23 |
91 | Alliance | -0.23 |
92 | Piqua | -0.27 |
93 | Sandusky | -0.28 |
94 | Washington Court House | -0.31 |
95 | Heath | -0.32 |
96 | Lancaster | -0.34 |
97 | Wooster | -0.43 |
98 | Barberton | -0.44 |
99 | Steubenville | -0.51 |
100 | Columbus | -0.56 |
101 | Youngstown | -0.59 |
102 | Hamilton | -0.62 |
103 | Circleville | -0.63 |
104 | Lorain | -0.66 |
105 | Cincinnati | -0.83 |
106 | Warren | -0.85 |
107 | Akron | -0.86 |
108 | Whitehall | -0.94 |
109 | Middletown | -0.94 |
110 | Lima | -1.01 |
111 | Springfield | -1.26 |
Methodology
We used the most recent FBI crime statistics to create state rankings. There were initially 7,430 cities in the data set. After filtering out the cities with populations of less than 10,000, 2,929 cities remained. We then calculated violent crime rates and property crime rates by dividing the crime numbers by the population to get rates per 1,000. We also calculated the ratio of law enforcement workers to per 1,000. These were weighted with -50% for the violent crime rate, -25% for the property crime rate, and +25% for the law enforcement rate. The resulting metric gave us a the safety index score. The higher this number more safe the city is.